Covered home entry with heavy timber framing, limestone walls, warm wood siding, and a closed glazed oak door above bluestone paving.

East Mitchell Street in Petoskey: What's Next for Restaurants

Why would someone who already holds a majority stake in 17 restaurants across northwest lower Michigan choose an empty storefront at the far end of Mitchell Street? Downtown Manager Amy Tweeten's memo to the Downtown Management Board says the new restaurant "would bring additional traffic to that end of downtown."

That end of downtown is upper Mitchell. It's the stretch of the 400 block where you'll pass papered windows, construction fencing and one building that has been dark for two holiday seasons. Each of those buildings now has a plan. Each plan is tied to a different public tool, and that tool sets the timeline better than any construction schedule does.

440 E. Mitchell and the seventh of ten licenses

The storefront at 440 E. Mitchell used to hold Tilly's Tafel and Petoskey Cheese, and both were second locations for those businesses. The new tenant is Petoskey 440 LLC, doing business as Margarita's Petoskey. The same applicant already runs a restaurant at 751 Spring Street, and its city filings call 440 E. Mitchell its "new location."

The space's next step runs through a liquor license. On October 20 the Downtown Management Board unanimously recommended a downtown redevelopment liquor license for the space, as the city's meeting summary reports. The application then went on City Council's November 5 agenda.

Downtown Petoskey has only a fixed number of these licenses, so each one counts. The cap has changed over time:

  1. 2011: Ordinance 727 created the program and allowed up to six licenses.
  2. 2018: Ordinance 760 raised the ceiling to ten.
  3. Now: If approved, Margarita's Petoskey would hold license number seven of the ten available.

The other six licenses went to places you probably already know: Beacon Bistro, whose license transferred from Twisted Olive; The Back Lot at 425 Michigan Street; Sam's Graces Café; Thai Orchid; the Crooked Tree Arts Council; and Happy's Taco Shop. The licenses don't belong to the businesses permanently. When a licensed business closes, state law requires its license to go back to the state, which happened once before downtown. The applicant also has to show that no regular license is available to buy in the city. The Michigan Liquor Control Commission makes the final call on that question.

When Council weighs these applications, one factor in the ordinance is whether the business "will contribute a new or unique choice to the mix of establishments" downtown. In practice, the cap on licenses helps decide which kinds of restaurants downtown gets.

Two doors down, a 131-year-old tavern with state money behind it

The license is 440's tool. At 434 E. Mitchell, the former Leo's Neighborhood Tavern, the tool is a financing package. The Michigan Economic Development Corporation announced on March 26 that the building will become eight homes, a restaurant and a speakeasy. Here's how it's paid for:

  • A $1.5 million grant from the state's Revitalization and Placemaking (RAP) program
  • A total planned investment of $5,335,575
  • A 12-year Obsolete Property Rehabilitation Act tax abatement from the City of Petoskey, worth about $330,000
  • A review by the State Historic Preservation Office, which found the design will have no negative impact on the historic building

The project also changes what the building can do. Four of the eight homes will share a common space, and each bedroom will have its own bathroom. The upper floors have never been ADA accessible, and the project brings the whole building into full compliance.

Developer Randy Flinn told the MEDC how much the project depended on that public support:

"From the outset, it was clear that restoring a 130-year-old structure of this scale would require strong public-private partnership. Without the support of the Michigan Economic Development Corporation, this project simply would not have been possible."

In the same statement, Flinn said the project was "just one year away" from delivering the apartments and "two vibrant hospitality spaces." Six weeks later, City Manager Shane Horn gave City Council an update that the Petoskey News-Review reported. The owner's financing was complete, historic tax credits had been granted, demolition was finished and interior walls were going up.

Put 434 and 440 together and two new places to eat and drink are coming to the same short stretch of upper Mitchell.

The corner where Petoskey's last department store stood

At Mitchell and Howard, the third project is moving on a private schedule. The J.C. Penney building opened in 1926 and was Petoskey's last traditional department store until it closed in October 2020. Upstairs, Petoskey Skyboxes condominiums are taking shape, and the ground floor is planned for retail. At the May council meeting, as the Petoskey News-Review reported, Horn said the owners had told him work was continuing, and that he understood it would "likely be another year before that project wraps up completely." October 19 council minutes still describe the building as under construction.

The street beside it has had public work of its own. Howard Street from Mitchell to Michigan was rebuilt with new curb, gutter, brick and concrete sidewalks, and upgraded water and sewer lines, on a capital plan budget of $605,000. City updates first aimed for mid-June and later moved the finish to late October. Nearby, the Park Garden lot was regraded and repaved and got storm sewer work, landscaping, new signs and a pay station on a $492,000 budget.

Across the street, the building the city wants sold

The fourth building has no restaurant, grant or condo plan yet. In this case the city is the one pushing for change. Emmet County found the buildings at 441, 443 and 445 E. Mitchell unsafe to occupy. It cited roof leaks, structural concerns with the floors, a fire-suppression system that didn't work, and problems with emergency exits, signage and lighting. The county ordered the buildings vacated by November 15, 2024. Jimmy John's had operated at 441 for 13 years and closed before that deadline. The Computer Source was at 445, and 443 was already empty.

In October, the Petoskey News-Review reported that the city had the property appraised at more than $3 million and wants a development partner to buy and redevelop it. Horn said the owners appear willing to sell at fair market value. He told the paper:

"We want to think outside of the box, so this (redevelopment) could include a demo and rebuild if needed."

A future project could include commercial space alone or commercial space with homes, depending on what a developer finds feasible. City Council has also been tightening its own rules. A proposed amendment to the city's vacant-buildings ordinance would require owners to renew their vacant-building registration every six months instead of once a year. It would also remove the exemption for buildings listed "For Sale." The amendment had its first reading on October 19 and was scheduled for second reading and possible adoption on November 5.

One block, four timelines

Address Most recent use Planned use Public tool behind it Last stated timing
440 E. Mitchell Tilly's Tafel, Petoskey Cheese Margarita's Petoskey Downtown redevelopment liquor license, 7 of 10 On Council's Nov. 5 agenda
434 E. Mitchell Leo's Neighborhood Tavern 8 homes, restaurant, speakeasy $1.5M RAP grant, 12-year tax abatement "One year away" as of March 2026
Mitchell and Howard J.C. Penney Petoskey Skyboxes condos, ground-floor retail Privately driven; Howard Street rebuilt alongside About a year out as of May 2026
441–445 E. Mitchell Jimmy John's, The Computer Source Commercial or mixed use, possibly a rebuild City-led sale search, vacant-building rules Developer search underway

The two buildings with the most public money and approvals behind them are the ones bringing restaurants back to this stretch first.

Walking the block this season

Upper Mitchell is part of downtown's holiday events, so you'll likely walk past all four buildings during at least one of them:

  • Thursday, November 12, 5:30 to 7 p.m.: Crooked Tree Arts Center's Holiday Vernissage & Swirl, with holiday shopping, live music and food. Tickets are $30 for members and $35 for nonmembers.
  • Friday, November 20, 4 to 8 p.m.: Ladies Opening Night, when participating shops offer specials, prizes and refreshments.
  • Saturday, November 28, 10 a.m.: The Downtown Petoskey Holiday Parade on Lake and Mitchell streets, with the Petoskey High School Marching Band, local nonprofits and Santa.
  • Friday, December 4, 6 to 9 p.m.: The Holiday Open House closes Lake and Mitchell to traffic, and the Petoskey High School Steel Drum Band makes its annual appearance.

On Open House night, with the street closed to cars, you can walk the whole block from 434 to 445 without dodging traffic.

If you own on or near upper Mitchell and want to know how these projects could affect your property, The Crane Group is glad to go through the block with you, building by building. Schedule a free consultation and we'll share what we're seeing downtown this winter.

Work with Johnny & Matt

Text to display: Johnny & Matt are two of Northern Michigan's most successful real estate agents and have helped hundreds of buyers and sellers achieve their real estate goals, resulting in over $100 Million of closed real estate transactions.

Follow Us on Instagram